Governor Paul LePage owes Maine people apologies
Maine's Governor Paul LePage created two Big Lies in recent weeks.
"During his time as governor, LePage often has used anecdotes to make his points, but he has been proven wrong on several occasions."- Portland Press Herald
First he brought unfounded fear to employees of "unnamed" Southern Maine companies when he said one of the employers was about to lay off 600 people; but never verified this story, and the depressing occurance has, thankfully, yet to happen. Now, most recently, he's violating the confidentiality of Portland's Deering High School students by making untrue accusations about an incident that never happened. A school student and the Portland Police Chief have debunked this lie.
Letter to the editor: LePage disparaged Deering with false story of overdose- letter from high school student
I am a junior at Deering High School. I thought I could share my opinion on the recent contention by Gov. LePage that a Deering student overdosed and was revived three times in one week.
I know for a fact that we did not have an overdose here at Deering. And I also know for a fact that the hypothetical student was not given Narcan, considering that we do not have it in the building. If EMTs are not allowed to carry it, why would a high school nurse be able to? It simply does not add up.
The cold hard truth is that LePage apparently needed reasons for why he vetoed the bill (for naloxone to be sold without prescription), and he did not have a solid reason. Therefore, he constructed some elaborate story about a Deering High School student who does not exist.
What I believe happened is that he was either confused or changed what happened last year in Deering Oaks, where someone had overdosed. What I do not understand is why he would change what actually happened.
We have a great school here in Portland, and great city officials and teachers for when things go wrong. If a student did overdose, they would have been rushed to Maine Medical Center or Mercy Hospital, not given Narcan and sent back to class.
None of it makes any sense. And I wanted to voice my thoughts on the complicated predicament from an insider’s perspective.
Hanna Amergian
Portland
Michael Sauschuck says the incident that LePage uses to oppose more access to Narcan involved a non-student at Deering Oaks, and lawmakers want an apology.
"During his time as governor, LePage often has used anecdotes to make his points, but he has been proven wrong on several occasions."- Portland Press Herald
First he brought unfounded fear to employees of "unnamed" Southern Maine companies when he said one of the employers was about to lay off 600 people; but never verified this story, and the depressing occurance has, thankfully, yet to happen. Now, most recently, he's violating the confidentiality of Portland's Deering High School students by making untrue accusations about an incident that never happened. A school student and the Portland Police Chief have debunked this lie.
 |
| Maine Governor Paul LePage should try to stick to his job as a politician, instead of telling lies to misrepresent the practice of medicine and treating substance abuse with therapeutic interventions. |
I know for a fact that we did not have an overdose here at Deering. And I also know for a fact that the hypothetical student was not given Narcan, considering that we do not have it in the building. If EMTs are not allowed to carry it, why would a high school nurse be able to? It simply does not add up.
What I believe happened is that he was either confused or changed what happened last year in Deering Oaks, where someone had overdosed. What I do not understand is why he would change what actually happened.
We have a great school here in Portland, and great city officials and teachers for when things go wrong. If a student did overdose, they would have been rushed to Maine Medical Center or Mercy Hospital, not given Narcan and sent back to class.
None of it makes any sense. And I wanted to voice my thoughts on the complicated predicament from an insider’s perspective.
Hanna Amergian
Portland
And more from Portland Maine's Police Chief:
Portland chief says LePage mistaken in account of overdoses at Deering High School
Michael Sauschuck says the incident that LePage uses to oppose more access to Narcan involved a non-student at Deering Oaks, and lawmakers want an apology.
Portland Police Chief Michael Sauschuck said Monday that Gov. Paul LePage was mistaken about an anecdote (ie "lie" IMO) he shared this month when he said a Deering High School student had overdosed and was revived three times before returning to class.
Sauschuck said the story the governor was told by Deering’s school resource officer, Steve Black, was about an overdose in Deering Oaks park and did not involve a student.
“I talked to Officer Black. The story was never about students. It was never about schools,” the chief said Monday night.
Sauschuck’s explanation came hours after LePage, appearing on the Maine Public Broadcasting Network, doubled down on his claim and then went further by suggesting that perhaps schools were not reporting overdoses.
“I’m thinking of calling (U.S.) Attorney General (Loretta) Lynch and asking for her investigative arm to come up and look at the school systems in Maine,” LePage said. “I think it’s serious enough. I believe it happened.”
The “it” in question is an anecdote that LePage shared May 4 during a town hall meeting in Lewiston while explaining his opposition to expanding access to the drug Narcan, also called naloxone, which reverses the effects of an opiate overdose.
“A junior at Deering High School had three Narcan shots in one week. And the third one, he got up and went to class. He didn’t go to the hospital. He didn’t get checked out. He was so used to it he just came out of it and went to class,” LePage said.
NO APOLOGY AFTER PRIVATE LETTER
Portland’s acting superintendent, Jeanne Crocker, and Deering High School Principal Ira Waltz immediately came out strongly against the claim.
“Unequivocally no. This did not happen at Deering High School,” Crocker said.
Waltz said the school doesn’t even have Narcan on campus.
On Monday, Democratic lawmakers from Portland ratcheted up pressure on LePage to apologize.
“Deering doesn’t deserve to have its reputation maligned by the highest elected leader in our state,” said Senate Democratic leader Justin Alfond of Portland. “The governor owes it to our community to set the record straight. Donald Trump may double down on his lies when confronted with the truth, but we can’t sit by while Gov. LePage makes up hurtful stories about our community.”
Portland-area lawmakers had sent a letter to LePage on May 11 asking him to apologize privately. They said he has remained silent, which prompted them to go public.
“It’s another example of ‘Ready, Fire, Aim.’ I can’t imagine how the governor came up with this story about our students and our high school,” said Rep. Erik Jorgensen, D-Portland, whose district includes Deering High. “This didn’t happen, plain and simple. He should check his facts. But more than that, he owes the hardworking students and faculty of Deering an apology.”
But LePage appeared to dig in even more during his radio remarks Monday.Audio Player
“It was not fabricated,” he said. “This is an actual conversation I had.”
Adrienne Bennett, the governor’s spokeswoman, declined to comment Monday or elaborate on what the governor said on the radio. She said LePage was told the anecdote by a school resource officer and that the police chief was in the room. She declined to identify either officer, although Portland has only one police chief, Sauschuck.
The chief said the governor and Officer Black spoke during an event last fall at the police department. Sauschuck said he wasn’t there for the entire conversation, but Black told him about the exchange.
“They were talking about heroin and (Black) shared the story of a very public overdose in Deering Oaks park,” Sauschuck said. He said LePage may have been confused because Black is a school resource officer during the school year, but was in the patrol unit when the park overdose happened during the summer.
STATE: YOUTH NARCAN USE IS STORY
A Deering High student, Hanna Amergian, predicted the Deering Oaks connection in a letter to the editor last week.
“The cold hard truth is that LePage apparently needed reasons for why he vetoed the bill (for naloxone to be sold without a prescription), and he did not have a solid reason. Therefore, he constructed some elaborate story about a Deering High School student who does not exist,” she wrote. “What I believe happened is that he was either confused or changed what happened last year in Deering Oaks, where someone had overdosed. What I do not understand is why he would change what actually happened.”
Rather than provide additional details about exactly where LePage heard the false anecdote, Bennett provided data compiled by the state’s emergency medical services agency on use of naloxone. It showed that nine people under the age of 18 were administered the drug statewide in 2015, but it did not say where those cases were or whether they were in schools. Another 107 people aged 18-24 were given the drug, Bennett pointed out, suggesting some “may be high school students.”
“It is very concerning to our governor that our youth are being administered Narcan shots,” she wrote in an email. “This is the story.”
Asked in a follow-up email why the governor didn’t share that data rather than the Deering High anecdote, Bennett did not respond.
HISTORY OF INACCURATE CLAIMS
During his time as governor, LePage often has used anecdotes to make his points, but he has been proven wrong on several occasions.
In 2012, he was speaking about the problems in Maine’s public schools and how that affected college applications when he said this: “If you go to William & Mary, apply to William & Mary, before they’ll look at your application, if you’re from a Maine school, you have to take a placement exam to see if you qualify.”
A spokeswoman for the college quickly corrected the governor, whose staff later said that LePage was working off information he received in 2005 from an unidentified employee at the school.
In April 2013, the governor used an anecdote to bolster his opposition to wind power. He claimed that a wind turbine on the campus of the University of Maine at Presque Isle was run by a “little electric motor that turns the blades.”
A university spokesperson laughed when asked about the claim and then said it was not true.
Last year, LePage insinuated that Maine author Stephen King spent more time in Florida to avoid paying full property taxes on his Bangor home.
King took to Twitter to fire back.
“Governor Paul LePage implied that I don’t pay my taxes. I do. Every cent. I think he needs to man up and apologize,” King wrote.
The governor did not.
Sauschuck said the story the governor was told by Deering’s school resource officer, Steve Black, was about an overdose in Deering Oaks park and did not involve a student.
Portland Police Chief Michael Sauschuck says Deering High's school resource officer told the governor about an overdose in Deering Oaks park. “The story was never about students," Sauchuck said. "It was never about schools." 2015 Press Herald file photo/Derek Davis
Search photos available for purchase: Photo Store →
“I talked to Officer Black. The story was never about students. It was never about schools,” the chief said Monday night.
Sauschuck’s explanation came hours after LePage, appearing on the Maine Public Broadcasting Network, doubled down on his claim and then went further by suggesting that perhaps schools were not reporting overdoses.
“I’m thinking of calling (U.S.) Attorney General (Loretta) Lynch and asking for her investigative arm to come up and look at the school systems in Maine,” LePage said. “I think it’s serious enough. I believe it happened.”
The “it” in question is an anecdote that LePage shared May 4 during a town hall meeting in Lewiston while explaining his opposition to expanding access to the drug Narcan, also called naloxone, which reverses the effects of an opiate overdose.
“A junior at Deering High School had three Narcan shots in one week. And the third one, he got up and went to class. He didn’t go to the hospital. He didn’t get checked out. He was so used to it he just came out of it and went to class,” LePage said.
NO APOLOGY AFTER PRIVATE LETTER
Portland’s acting superintendent, Jeanne Crocker, and Deering High School Principal Ira Waltz immediately came out strongly against the claim.
“Unequivocally no. This did not happen at Deering High School,” Crocker said.
Waltz said the school doesn’t even have Narcan on campus.
On Monday, Democratic lawmakers from Portland ratcheted up pressure on LePage to apologize.
“Deering doesn’t deserve to have its reputation maligned by the highest elected leader in our state,” said Senate Democratic leader Justin Alfond of Portland. “The governor owes it to our community to set the record straight. Donald Trump may double down on his lies when confronted with the truth, but we can’t sit by while Gov. LePage makes up hurtful stories about our community.”
Portland-area lawmakers had sent a letter to LePage on May 11 asking him to apologize privately. They said he has remained silent, which prompted them to go public.
“It’s another example of ‘Ready, Fire, Aim.’ I can’t imagine how the governor came up with this story about our students and our high school,” said Rep. Erik Jorgensen, D-Portland, whose district includes Deering High. “This didn’t happen, plain and simple. He should check his facts. But more than that, he owes the hardworking students and faculty of Deering an apology.”
But LePage appeared to dig in even more during his radio remarks Monday.Audio Player
“It was not fabricated,” he said. “This is an actual conversation I had.”
Adrienne Bennett, the governor’s spokeswoman, declined to comment Monday or elaborate on what the governor said on the radio. She said LePage was told the anecdote by a school resource officer and that the police chief was in the room. She declined to identify either officer, although Portland has only one police chief, Sauschuck.
The chief said the governor and Officer Black spoke during an event last fall at the police department. Sauschuck said he wasn’t there for the entire conversation, but Black told him about the exchange.
“They were talking about heroin and (Black) shared the story of a very public overdose in Deering Oaks park,” Sauschuck said. He said LePage may have been confused because Black is a school resource officer during the school year, but was in the patrol unit when the park overdose happened during the summer.
STATE: YOUTH NARCAN USE IS STORY
A Deering High student, Hanna Amergian, predicted the Deering Oaks connection in a letter to the editor last week.
“The cold hard truth is that LePage apparently needed reasons for why he vetoed the bill (for naloxone to be sold without a prescription), and he did not have a solid reason. Therefore, he constructed some elaborate story about a Deering High School student who does not exist,” she wrote. “What I believe happened is that he was either confused or changed what happened last year in Deering Oaks, where someone had overdosed. What I do not understand is why he would change what actually happened.”
Rather than provide additional details about exactly where LePage heard the false anecdote, Bennett provided data compiled by the state’s emergency medical services agency on use of naloxone. It showed that nine people under the age of 18 were administered the drug statewide in 2015, but it did not say where those cases were or whether they were in schools. Another 107 people aged 18-24 were given the drug, Bennett pointed out, suggesting some “may be high school students.”
“It is very concerning to our governor that our youth are being administered Narcan shots,” she wrote in an email. “This is the story.”
Asked in a follow-up email why the governor didn’t share that data rather than the Deering High anecdote, Bennett did not respond.
HISTORY OF INACCURATE CLAIMS
During his time as governor, LePage often has used anecdotes to make his points, but he has been proven wrong on several occasions.
In 2012, he was speaking about the problems in Maine’s public schools and how that affected college applications when he said this: “If you go to William & Mary, apply to William & Mary, before they’ll look at your application, if you’re from a Maine school, you have to take a placement exam to see if you qualify.”
A spokeswoman for the college quickly corrected the governor, whose staff later said that LePage was working off information he received in 2005 from an unidentified employee at the school.
In April 2013, the governor used an anecdote to bolster his opposition to wind power. He claimed that a wind turbine on the campus of the University of Maine at Presque Isle was run by a “little electric motor that turns the blades.”
A university spokesperson laughed when asked about the claim and then said it was not true.
Last year, LePage insinuated that Maine author Stephen King spent more time in Florida to avoid paying full property taxes on his Bangor home.
King took to Twitter to fire back.
“Governor Paul LePage implied that I don’t pay my taxes. I do. Every cent. I think he needs to man up and apologize,” King wrote.
The governor did not.
Labels: Hanna Amergian, Narcan, Police Chief Michael Sauschuck, Portland Press Herald
posted by Juliana L'Heureux | 5:20 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home