Maine Writer

Its about people and issues I care about.

My Photo
Name:
Location: Topsham, MAINE, United States

My blogs are dedicated to the issues I care about. Thank you to all who take the time to read something I've written.

Monday, January 20, 2020

Florence Nightingale and the Year of the Nurse

Science and Technology

"At the same time, as diagnostic systems and surgical robots advance, nursing may be the only aspect of the health-care profession in which machines will not replace human beings." 

Nursing Summit in Augusta Maine - Nightingale exhibit 

THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION has designated 2020 as the “Year of the Nurse”, marking 200 years since the birth of Florence Nightingale, who established the principles of modern nursing and hospital sanitation. If she were to drop in on a hospital today, Nightingale would be pleased to see the progress in nursing since her day—and how it is poised to change in the years to come.

Nightingale founded the first nursing school, at a hospital in London in 1860, and wrote some 200 books and papers. She was the first woman admitted to the Royal Statistical Society, for her pioneering work in statistical infographics. While tending to British soldiers in the Crimean war, she made the case for hospital sanitation using a variation of the pie chart, entitled “Diagram of the Causes of Mortality in the Army in the East”, to show that more soldiers died from infections than from injuries. She drew up the chart to “affect through the Eyes what we may fail to convey to the brains of the public through their word-proof ears”. In what became known as a Coxcomb diagram, each slice of the pie has the same angular width and an area representing the amount in a given category (such as number of dead men).

Many, if not most, people today think of nursing as a narrow set of skills learned on the ward, much like it was back in Nightingale’s time. In fact, nurses have university degrees and there are doctorate-level studies in nursing. Like doctors, nurses specialise in myriad clinical disciplines, such as neonatology, cardiology and Accident & Emergency. There are even forensic nurses. Such is the pace of innovation in nursing that some issues of American Nurse Today, a monthly journal, run north of 70 pages.


In 2020 and beyond nurses will be doing a growing number of tasks conventionally reserved for doctors, both in acute and chronic care. Already, nearly two-thirds of anaesthetics given to patients in America are administered by certified nurse anaesthetists. In Britain specialised nurses now perform some types of abdominal, orthopaedic and cardiac surgery. In parts of sub-Saharan Africa nurses are being trained to do emergency caesarean sections, with results comparable to those achieved by doctors.

The changing face of nursing

Nurses will be increasingly tapped to replace general practitioners in treating patients with diabetes and other chronic conditions that require lifestyle changes. Nurses are particularly well placed to provide this kind of holistic care, which takes into account each person’s life circumstances, because they have long been patients’ confidants. In the words of Brian Dolan, an academic, “people look up to a doctor, but they look a nurse in the eye.” In surveys about trust in people from various professions, nurses invariably come top.

What would disappoint Nightingale in her time-travel to the present is that the transformation of nursing has been uneven. In countries as varied as India, Germany and Portugal nurses are still largely treated as doctors’ minions and may not even diagnose common ailments or prescribe medication. And although nurses make up nearly half of the world’s health-care workforce—and 90% of patients’ contacts with health workers—they are often not at the table when health-policy decisions are made. Even the World Health Organisation did not have a chief nursing officer until 2018.

The other trend that would make Nightingale furrow her brow is that nursing has lost its lustre, so most posts are hard to fill. In many countries no profession has a higher number of vacancies. In the next decade the shortage of nurses will remain the biggest problem that national health systems all over the world will face. By 2030 the world will be short of 7.6m nurses, which is a third of their number today.

To turn this tide, efforts to draw more people into nursing and keep trained nurses from leaving the profession will accelerate. Countries will focus more on recruiting nurses locally, rather than luring them from abroad—often from poor places where health care is already crippled by nurse shortages. National media campaigns will aim to raise the profile of nursing by dispelling outdated views about what the job entails. Some may borrow ideas from Singapore’s highly effective campaign, which has commissioned nursing dramas, documentaries and even a “nursing anthem” (in the form of a catchy pop-music video). The campaign’s Instagram account has something for everyone, including love stories of couples who met in nursing school.

Prodded by a global campaign which began in 2018, more hospitals and other employers will set up professional-development and leadership programmes for nurses. There will be more talk—and, it is hoped, action too—about how to enable nurses to work at the top of their licence and abilities. Technology will be roped in to make their work more manageable and reduce burnout. Algorithms, for example, will be used to map the optimal routes for ward shifts.

At the same time, as diagnostic systems and surgical robots advance, nursing may be the only aspect of the health-care profession in which machines will not replace human beings. 

Even though nursing is shaped by medical science and technology, as it has been since Nightingale’s time, its healing powers remain rooted in empathy and a human touch.

This article appeared in the Science and Technology section of the print edition under the headline "Florence and the machine".

Slavea Chankova: health-care correspondent, The Economist

Labels: , ,

Saturday, November 23, 2019

Nurses call to care for migrants- an ethical imperative

This echo nursing opinion by Leah Curtin was published in American Nurse Today. 

From Where I Stand on the last page opinion column:  

Must nurses care for migrants?
To deny basic human right to any person for any reason is ipso facto* unethical!
Basic human rights apply to everyone.

There seems to be much controversy about giving healthcare to "undocumented" immigrants- or even "documented" ones. In fact, some people believe that anyone who doesn't have health insurance has no right to healthcare. According to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, they are wrong. And what's even worse is when a government not only doesn't uphold the right but actually violates it.  For example, the treatment of migrant children on the U.S. southern border is a gross violation of these children's basic rights on several levels.  Period. Full stop. It isn't a matter of politics or party. It's a matter of basic human rights. Nothing that their parents do or fail to do has any bearing on their rights as human beings.

How dare I say such a think?  Let's go back to the United Nations' Universal Declaration of Human Rights, of which the United States is a signatory. What follows comes directly from the declaration:

"Article 1:  All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.  They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood."

"Article 2:  Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration, without distinction of any kind, such as race, color, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status.  Furthermore, no distinction shalt be made on the basis of the political jurisdictional or international status of the country or territory to which a person belongs, whether it be independent, trust, non-self-governing or under any other limitation of sovereignty."

"Article 25: Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical are and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control. Motherhood and childhood are entitled to special care and assistance. All children, whether born in or out of wedlock, shall enjoy the same social protection."

Perhaps it is worth the time to refresh our understanding about human rights. Human rights are just claims to the fulfillment of fundamental, universal human needs. They don't depend on any legal jurisdiction, but they do need to be claimed, but you aren't less human if they're violated. No one can live a full human life, without them and in some cases they can't live at all without them.  

Human rights can be violated, but they don't go away because they're violated.  In act, their violation demands retribution. They don't disappear when one crosses state or national boundaries- whether or not that state or nation recognizes and protects them in their existing jurisdictions.

So, if you want to know if nurses have an ethical obligation to care for undocumented immigrants, the answer is a resounding "yes". To refuse to care for them is, ipso facto, unethical.

By Leah Curtin, RN, ScD (h), FAAN
Executive Editor, Professional Outreach
American Nurse Today

*ipso facto: Latin meaning "by the very fact".

Hillary Clinton quote:  "....human rights are women's rights, and women's rights are human rights, once and for all...."

“I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me.” Matthew 25:35

Labels: , , , , ,

Sunday, September 22, 2019

Nurses call for stopping the inhumanity to immigrants and migrants

They are human beings. They are us!- Dr. Grant, ANA president. Published in American Nurse Today, September 2019.

I am pleased to blog this commentary, by the American Nurses Association President Dr. Ernest J. Grant.


NPR- Migrant Kids Survive Hardship To Reunite With Parents.

Advocating for improved conditions and access to healthcare for migrant children and families.

We've all seen and heard the countless media reports about the deplorable conditions in migrant detention centers:  young children taking care of even younger children, no access to basic hygiene products and clean clothes, freezing temperatures, and overcrowded, squalid conditions. Words like appalling, shocking and disturbing have been used by the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, members of Congress, and others to describe what they've observed after being allowed to visit some of the detention centers.  

These accounts have only served to galvanize us. As nurses, we see a need and we act.

We see a wrong and we want it righted.

We are advocates, and that role, especially speaking up for vulnerable populations like these detained children who can't possibly understand why this is happening to them, is defined by our Code of Ethics, our nursing standards, and our long standing social justice mission.



Many nurses have contacted the American Nurses Association (ANA) and more recently me personally about what they- and we as a national nurses' association- can do to stop this inhumane treatment. These nurses also expressed a desire to provide healthcare to children and migrant families who are suffering physically, mentally and emotionally.  Many of these families are asylum seekers who already are traumatized by violence, war and extreme poverty.

Since this crisis began, ANA has been engaged in a series of outreach efforts to federal officials about our concerns and to convey nurses' willingness to help.  

Most recently, our governing body, the ANA Membership Assembly, overwhelmingly approved a resolution asking that ANA again reach out to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), to voice our grave concerns about detention center conditions. In a letter sent to DHA (bit.ly/20dWgxs), we asked that an expert task force, including nurses, be convened to review and adopt best practices to ensure detained immigrants' health and safety. We also requested that detained migrants have the opportunity for quick and fair hearings.

When it comes to complex issues, such as immigration policy and border security, we know that nurses and the greater public have varying personal and political viewpoints. But, one thing we should all be able to agree on is that every child - every living person- should be treated humanly in all circumstances and have access to health care. 

As of this writing, the media have published reports about 24 death of immigrants who have been in U.S. custody, including seven children.  In addition, cases of contagious diseases, such as chickenpox, mumps, and influenza have been reported at detention centers. And, research has pointed to the long-term physical and mental health effects, such as post-traumatic stress disorder, experienced by the detained people.

After outrage over deaths at the border and certain detention center conditions, Congress passed emergency supplemental funding to help alleviate this humanitarian crisis. More needs to be done, but ongoing differences among elected officials about reforming immigration policies make this difficult to achieve.

ANA's efforts so far have largely focused on addressing migrant families' health and well-being. We will continue reaching out to federal officials, including requests for greater transparency around detention center conditions and the provision of quality, timely, healthcare.

ANA and the nursing profession have a long and strong tradition for shining a light on humanitarian issues and using our nursing knowledge and skills to assist vulnerable popuplations in any way we can. For those of you who feel passionate about this issue, seek out ways you can help migrant families through your communities and other key organizations, such as the American Red Cross (and Rotary International). We recently developed a resource guide to assist (tinyurl.com/yyc2xpkt) and you can reference ANA and healthcare for imigrants (bit.ly/2y1WigB).

As nurses, we can't sit silent. We must advocate. These detained children and adults deserve better than what we've been seeing and hearing. They are human beings. They are us.

Ernest J. GRant, Ph.D., R.N., FAAN
President, American Nurses Association

Labels: , , , ,

Saturday, July 28, 2018

Nursing compassion ~ learning with knowledge and experience

Compassion
Leah Curtin ScD(h), RN, FAAN, is Clinical Professor of Nursing at the University of Cincinnati College of Nursing and Health 

"Compassion: A nurse's primary virtue" was published in the July 2018, "American Nurse Today".

Strengthening compassion may help you avoid burnout.

Nurses, we’re told, are fundamentally compassionate people. In fact, nurse burnout could be defined as the loss of compassion. So, it behooves us as nurses to explore what compassion is, how it differs from empathy and sympathy, and how to enhance it.
Compassion, empathy, and sympathy.


The etymology of compassion is Latin, and it means “co-suffering.” It involves feeling for another, and it’s considered a precursor to empathy, which is feeling what another feels. When you empathize, you share the suffering of another—an emotion that’s not especially helpful for nurses.

In nursing, compassion is active; our education and experience have provided us with the ability to relieve another’s suffering. It often confers the capacity for person-centered acts that relieve suffering. The difference between sympathy and compassion is that sympathy responds to suffering with sorrow and concern while compassion responds with warmth and care.

Compassion is more than a desire to alleviate another’s suffering, it involves the ability and the will to do so. Compassion can be broken down into four interrelated stages:
recognizing that there is suffering (cognitive)
being emotionally moved by that suffering (affective)
wanting to relieve that suffering (intentional)
having the ability and willingness to take action to relieve that suffering (motivational).

In short, compassion isn’t defined by what you feel for another but what you do about what you feel. Moreover, an act of compassion is defined by its helpfulness. That is, the efficacy of compassion can be defined by whether the action taken is of service or assistance to the one who’s suffering. Being of service or assistance doesn’t necessarily involve making things easier for the sufferer or even necessarily relieving his or her pain. It depends on the cause of the suffering, the person’s response to the suffering, and the personality of the sufferer. That’s why a compassionate nursing response is always person-centric.

Strengthen your compassion

Contrary to what many may believe, compassion is more like a muscle than an emotion; thus, as with any muscle, it can be strengthened with relevant exercises—or can deteriorate and atrophy. In other words, your capacity for compassion can expand, if you choose. Preliminary research from a variety of randomized controlled trials suggests that compassion can be enhanced through systematic training programs. For example:
  • Meditate daily, even if only for a few minutes.
  • Notice when compassion comes easily or spontaneously for you throughout the day.
  • Start noticing suffering (your own and that of others) and allow yourself to be emotionally touched or moved by the suffering. 
  • Awareness of the presence or absence of compassion can provide you with some valuable information.
To foster resilience, think about a hurtful event in a different way.
Be compassionate toward yourself. No empirical evidence exists to suggest that beating ourselves up changes our behavior.

Compassion, which is ranked as a great virtue in numerous philosophies and almost all major religious traditions, certainly is a virtue for all nurses—ranking in importance right next to knowledge and experience!











Leah Curtin, RN, ScD(h), FAAN
Executive Editor, Professional Outreach

Labels: ,

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Nurse robots? In a universe of possibilities it had to happen- but not so fast!

Obviously, nurses don't want to think of ourselves as being replaceable. We are especially adverse to being taken over by "nurse robots". Nevertheless, this wave of high tech but "no touch" care is more reality than sci-fi, especially given the enormity of the projected nursing shortage coupled with an aging population.

This may be a landmark Lillee Gelinas article, published in 2017. Yet, in about 10 years (or less) nurses will likely find this robotics news as ho-hum as reading about how only physicians were once upon a time considered qualified to take patients' blood pressures or listen to lung sounds. Robots can do a lot.
Related image
But, not so fast!  Robots can't think in ambiguities. IOW, "I felt better yesterday than I do today"; "Can I drive my car after surgery?" 

(Robotic nurses? Say it ain't so! Well, yes, certainly it is so; but nurses must climb to a professional level of expertise where we're able to master what the robot can't do- which is to really care about the patient. Robots cannot assess a patient's family situation or their capacity to achieve wellness.)

Robotic nurses: No substitute for real RNs
February 2017 Vol. 12 No. 2 
Author: Lillee Gelinas, MSN, RN, FAAN

For the past decade, care innovation has exploded with new tools and technology. Keeping up with all of the new devices and gadgets available to ease caregiver burden and increase safety is hard. One machine that’s gaining a lot of attention and investment lately is the robotic nurse, also known as the nursebot.

What’s fueling the rapid development of automated caregivers? I believe it’s the result of three major trends: growth of an aging population, advances in technology and information systems, and never-ending nursing shortages.

As nurses, we’re used to seeing robots filling and delivering medications in pharmacies, assisting in the operating room, and supporting telehealth strategy. But can robots deliver nursing care? Yes, according to several experts and current research.
Social urgency: the aging population

Today, people live longer and have fewer children than past generations, creating a larger elderly population relative to a shrinking labor force. The Department of Health and Human Services Administration on Aging (DHHSAA) estimates that by 2030, the 65-and-older population in the United States will reach 72 million, compared to 46.2 million in 2014.
New technology for caregiving

In Japan, where nearly 30% of the population is over 65, its birth rate is low, and not enough people are entering the workforce to care for the elderly, a proposed solution includes robotic nurses. Japan has several versions of robotic nurses that can perform simple tasks, like taking vital signs and moving patients.

In the United States, Duke University’s School of Engineering and School of Nursing have collaborated to create the Tele-Robotic Intelligent Nursing Assistant (TRINA). Nurses and physicians remotely navigate this robot without entering a patient’s room. TRINA can transport linens, take vital signs, and deliver food and medications. Since the Ebola outbreaks, robots and other technologies are being tested to diminish risks for providers who care for patients with infectious diseases.


Researchers from the University of Michigan, University of Pittsburgh, and Carnegie Mellon University are working on a nursebot called Pearl. This assistive robot reminds patients about routine activities such as taking medications and guides them through their environment as needed.

Ethics and decision making

With demands for caregivers growing, seeking technology solutions that fill the gap makes sense. 

Nevertheless, a robot isn’t a substitute for the essence of our profession—assessment, critical thinking, and therapeutic high-touch skills. On the other hand, if robots can support basic patient needs and give nurses more time to do what they do best, then everyone can benefit.

Questions about robotic technology focus on ethics and decision making. For instance, can a machine be programmed with 1) a reliable set of ethics; 2) the ability to assess a clinical situation and make judgments about the correct clinical course of action; and 3) the capacity to respond appropriately to ambiguous situations? Right now, the answer is no.

Current robot prototypes are designed as nursing assistants to supplement care. It’s an important distinction, so our terminology should reflect that. Robots are care assistants and that’s the only way we should refer to them. Rest easy. 

There’s no substitute for the real RN. (Of course not!)

Lillee Gelinas, MSN, RN, FAAN

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

Human Trafficking: A tragic public safety issue- victims need care

Nurses are considered mandatory reporters for suspected minor age (under 18) human trafficking victims.

"....and a crime against humanity..." Cheryl Green MSN, RN, CNL

"...many victims suffer from chronic untreated diseases, such as tuberculosis, diabetes or asthma, as well as infestations, poor dentition, dehydration, and malnutrition."

"Victims who are immigrants were probably told that authority figures are the enemy and will seek to arrest or deport them."

Although Republicans are obstinately resistant to progressive changes in the US immigration laws, the facts are accumulating to show how human trafficking is becoming a public safety issue and even tangentially related to illegal immigration, because victims often feel like they're criminals. In fact, while illegal immigrants are worried about being deported, the victims of human traffiking are frightened, because they must hide in the shadows or face criminal charges, plus deportation. Moreover, many of them are physically and emotionally ill, suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder and are victims of domestic violence.
Stop Human Trafficking Graphic
A nurse may be a victim's only point of contact outside of captivity. It's mandatory for nurses to report human trafficking of minor age children.
In other words, human trafficking is the darkest side of the illegal immigration issue. Worse, it's unlikely the trafficking will stop, just because immigration reform happnes to be resolved.

Public health is at risk for infectious diseases with this growing trafficking problem, because the victims of are usually living in poverty, or worse, and not receiving the benefit of medical care. They're a lost population. 

In the magazine, American Nurse Today, an article by Cheryl Green, MSN, RN, CNL, defines the human trafficking issues.
She calls it a "crime against humanity". 

IN MOST WAYS, human trafficking (modern slavery) is no different from slavery of ancient times: it's brutal, highly profitable business with  no regard for its victims. Trafficking is a crime but it's often difficult for medical providers to recognize the victims and to identify how to help them.

Human trafficking falls into two broad categories:
1.  Labor trafficking- typically is either forced hard labor, usually in agriculture or textile sweatshops; or domestic labor, such as working as a nanny or house servant.
2.  Sex trafficking - involves forced work in strip clubs, massage parlors, pornography production or prostituion. It also may involved  mail-order brides.  

"Human trafficking: Preparing for a unique patient population", by Green describes the most prevalent form of slavery in the United States being "sex trafficking". 

An estimated 14, 500 to 17,500 people are trafficked into the US annually and 100,000 to 200,000 American minors are exploited in the sex industry. Worlwide, 2 million children and young women are trapped in sex slavery.  

Consequences for the victims 
Human trafficking victims face grave physical and emotional dangers every day. Research suggests initial gang rape is a common method of recruitment into slavery. Threats of repeated rape, if the victim doesn't comply with demands, are common.  Some victims rescued from the sex trade report customers who didn't like condoms and paid extra to avoid using them.  This puts victims at great risk for sexually transmitted infections, unplanned pregnancy and physical trauma from rape.

Physical abuse, rampant in the trafficking business, is a primary means of forcing victims to comply. A study of European trafficking victims found about 75 percent were kicked, punched in the face, burned with cigarettes, hit with objects, dragged by their hair or struck in the head. More than half had post-traumatic stress (PTSD) disorder. Also, many victims then abuse or become addicted to the drugs or alcohol, given to them by their traffickers (sometimes by force) to control them. What's more, many victims suffer from chronic untreated diseases, such as tuberculosis, diabetes or asthma, as well as infestations, poor dentition, dehydration, and malnutrition.

These facts underscore the immediate and imperative need for healthcare advocacy for victims. Unfortunately, caregivers, nurses, the public at large or public safety professionals may have limited knowledge about how to identify victims of human trafficking, especially in the healthcare setting.

Helping to rescue victims
A nurse may be the trafficking victims only point of contact with the environment outside of captivity. To help rescue victims from a horrific life they didn't choose, healthcare providers need to become knowledgeable about this crime against humanity.

Implications for nurses
In 2014, Katherien Chon, senior adviser on Trafficking in Persons, for the US Dept. of Health and Human Services, testified before Congress that roughly 75 percent of trafficked women saw a healthcare provider while they were in captivity. In most cases, this provider was in an emergency department (ED). Indeed, they are obviously seen in the most expensive emergent care setting without opportunity for follow up or access to primary preventive care.

Nevertheless, many trafficking victims can be identified in other settings where health clinics, acute-care hospital units, dental offices and jails.  This encounter may be a victim's only possible entry point into the social safety nets, yet many many trafficking victims aren't identified as such in healthcare settings. Once this opportunity to identify them is lost, it may never arise again, because traffickers typically don't allow visits to care providers unless a victim's health is so precarious that she or he can't work.

Even victims who seek care may go unrecognized or be mistaken for domestic violence victims, drug addicts or prostitutes.  

Failure to identify a trafficking victim in a health care facility can lead to tragic consequences or even death for that person.  

Nurses are front line caregivers and therefore have the opportunity to identify victims and refer them to appropriate resources.

Recognizing trafficking victims
Although human trafficking and domestic violence victims share some common presentations, important differences exist. For example, domestic violence victims usually fear one abuser, whereas trafficking victims may fear many people because they may have multiple abusers.  (If a victim is assessed for having poorly healed fractures or signs of repeated strains, this is an assessment for trafficking....)

Victims who are immigrants probably have been told that authority figures are the enemy and will seek to arrest or deport them.

Consequently, they may fear a uniform, including a nurses uniform. Also, trafficking victims tend to be more isolated than domestic violence victims, to suffer disease or malnutrition and to have little or no family contact. Also, they're more likely to be victims of substance abuse.  

Some victims, although cognitively intact, may be unable to verbalize their current location, if asked. This is especially true of those trafficked into the United State from other countries. Not only are the victims in unfamiliar surroundings, but they may see little of their outside world and may not even know where they are.

Be aware that adults and children who've been coerced into prostitution in the United States aren't (not!) considered criminals. On the contrary, they're victims of human trafficking and protected under the federal Trafficking Victims Protection Act. 

In fact, persons younger than age 18 who are involved in commercial sex exploitation fall into the legal criteria for minor sex trafficking, their traffickers are prosecutable under the law. Nurses are considered mandatory reporters for suspected minor (under 18) human trafficking victims.

Approaching a suspected victim
If you suspect a person or patient of yours is a trafficking victim, consider how to best approach him or her. Never ask outright if she or he is a trafficking victim, especially if a companion is present. Most victims probably don't know what the term "trafficking" means. What's more, few people, no matter how dire their circumstances, want to be called a victim, because they're trying to retain as much dignity as possible. 

If a patient doesn't speak English, call for a medical interpreter.
Be prepared for the companion to insist that he or she can interpret, but decline this offer, explaining that facility policy allows only for certified medical interpreters. Also, consider cultural factors. For example, female victims from patriarchal cultures typically are unwilling to speak for themselves, the same, of course, for minors.

Anticipate that victims will resist help. Feelings of intense fear, shame, and helplessness may even compel some to try to leave the facility without treatment. In some cases, a companion who senses that authorities suspect the true nature of the situation may force the victim to leave. Therefore, if you suspect trafficking, make sure a staff member stays with the victim at all times. (In fact, one way to assess the risk of a person being a trafficking victim is the sense that he or she is under surveillance, at all times.)  Keep in mind, of course, that many immigrants and other foreigners can't read, write or speak Englsh and are accompanied to the hospital by companions who speak for them, yet are not trafficking victims. Consequently, be careful not to base a trafficking assessment solely on these characteristics -  but diligence to the issue will alert the nurse to any unusual interacton or situation.

Human trafficking victims don't receive preventive helth care, so by the time emergency or clinic providers encounter them, many health conditions may have become serious and vcitims may be in dire health circumstances. With this in mind, conduct a head-to-toe nursing assessment, providing as much privacy & comfort as possible.  

Asking certain questions can help determine if the patient is a trafficking victim, without causing fear or alienation.

Be aware that repeated violent penetration may  cause vaginal or anal fistulas. Even young women may have bowel or bladder incontinence, or both.  Many trafficking victims have positive drug screens, infectious diseases, live or scabies infestations or tattoos with brands of gang symbols, trafficker initials or even barcodes.


Psycho-social issues are prevalent among this population. Although victims may have pronounced anxiety or panic, some may even be stoic, almost to the point of complete withdrawal.

Finally, lack of trust may lead victims to suspect you're trying to trap them into revealing information as a test of loyalty to the trffficker, putting the victim, or the victims's family, in danger. Establishing trust is difficult but crucial (!) because the trafficker most likely is the only person the victim feels they can trust and rely on.

Cheryl Green is a cardiac/medical-surgical nurse at Cone Health Alamance Regional Medical Center in Burlington, North Carolina.

The National Human Trafficking Resource Center is a resource for more information:  1-888-373-7888,  Consider posting the phone number where patients can see it.







Labels: , , ,