Maine Writer

Its about people and issues I care about.

My Photo
Name:
Location: Topsham, MAINE, United States

My blogs are dedicated to the issues I care about. Thank you to all who take the time to read something I've written.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Republicans are wrong to interfere with women's health and access to reproductive care

 How overturning Roe vs. Wade hurt the health of every American

Echo opinion published in the Los Angeles Times by Robin Abcarian

Obviously, the conservative members of the Supreme Court had no understanding about what they were unleashing on the people of this country when they overturned Roe vs. Wade in 2022, effectively ending the federal right to abortion
❓

Do you think they understood that allowing states to determine their own laws regarding abortion would result in women sitting in parking lots while miscarrying, because doctors believed they had to wait for a woman’s organs to fail before performing life-saving abortions
❓ Or that a pregnant woman with cancer who needs an abortion to start life-saving chemo treatments would be denied proper care❓

Did the justices know that women of reproductive age would no longer be included in some medical studies because the treatments being studied might have adverse effects on fetuses — even if the women were not pregnant, had no plans to get pregnant and did not plan to stay pregnant if they became so
❓

Did the justices understand that they’d be stymieing research on conditions like Gulf War illness — in which veterans with chemical exposures suffer from rashes, muscle pain and brain fog — because a promising treatment, mifepristone, also happens to be used as an abortifacient❓

These grotesque outcomes of the court’s Dobbs vs. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision are detailed in an important new book, “Side Effects: How Abortion Bans Affect Everyone’s Health,” by journalist Alice Miranda Ollstein, who covers reproductive health for Politico.

I would love to send copies to the six justices who blithely overturned Roe, especially to Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who wondered during oral arguments why women couldn’t just avail themselves of safe haven laws if they didn’t want children. 

Just drop that newborn off at the local firehouse and go on your merry way❗😔😕😒😞😡

Or, that pharmacists would refuse to fill prescriptions for women of child-bearing age on the off-chance that the medications they needed for lupus, arthritis or psoriasis might cause abortions, even when the women were in no danger of becoming pregnant because they, for example, had had hysterectomies❓

But Ollstein, 38, said she did not spend time pondering whether the justices understood or cared about the implications of their decision.

“I wanted to focus on what the consequences have been, because that’s not speculation,” Ollstein told me Wednesday. “We don’t have to guess what’s in somebody’s mind and heart. We can see in hard data and people’s real stories what the repercussions are. In one sense, it almost doesn’t matter what the intent was. This is the result.”

The result is a country where women are forced to cross state lines to receive abortion care. Where doctors are choosing not to practice (and residents are refusing to train) in states with draconian antiabortion laws, such as Idaho, Kentucky and Tennessee. Where military veterans cannot obtain abortions from Veterans Affairs even in case of rape or to save the mother’s life.

Where clinics that don’t even provide abortions anymore have been forced to shutter, depriving patients of access to HIV testing, contraception, PAP smears and breast exams.

And of course, where women are dying because doctors are terrified that giving appropriate medical care will result in criminal charges.

The simple truth is that legislating medical care can have terrible consequences, and politicians have no business doing it.


As Ollstein told me, “If you make the exception broad — ’You can only intervene in a life-threatening circumstance’ — it’s vague and people don’t know when they’re allowed to act. If you make it very specific — ‘You can have an abortion if your blood pressure is this exact number’ — no list can ever be comprehensive. Being too specific may be just as dangerous as being too broad.”

Having covered the abortion beat as a news reporter shortly after President Obama was first elected, I’ve always believed that Americans will never be able to reach a middle ground on reproductive rights. The sides are too polarized.

What I failed to realize, and what Ollstein pointed out, was that in Roe vs. Wade, we already had one.

“Many people argue Roe was the middle ground because it allowed states to impose restrictions later in pregnancy but had national protections for abortions earlier in pregnancy,” Ollstein said. “That was already a compromise because a lot of people believe there should be no restrictions at any point in pregnancy. That was the contested, uneasy compromise that held for 50 years, and now we’re in a new era.”

Thanks to the recent midterm elections, the aftershocks of Dobbs are about to give way to a new political reality. The reordering of power from red to blue in state legislatures, governor’s mansions and Congress is good news for those who believe Dobbs inflicted terrible unforeseen consequences.

“People should also pay attention to state attorneys general seats that flipped,” Ollstein said. “Those are very influential on abortion.”

Indeed, both Texas and Kansas were part of lawsuits trying to force the Food and Drug Administration to restrict abortion pills, but their new Democratic attorneys general have signaled they will not continue those fights.

The Supreme Court returned the power to regulate or outlaw abortion to the states, Ollstein said, “as though it was putting it to bed and washing its hands of the issue. That’s already proven untrue.”

In fact, the court has repeatedly had to address secondary conflicts over things like access to medication abortion, federal emergency care mandates and Medicaid provider exclusions.

As long as there are people who want to control women’s bodies, and people who refuse to let that happen, the battle over abortion in America will not go away anytime soon.


Labels: , ,

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

RKjr-- iOW Robert F. Kennedy Jr. responsible for measles homicides

Americans are Dying of (Preventable❗)Measles

Echo opinion published in The New York Times by Dr. Perri Klass

RFKjr and Donald Trump are responsible for this preventable Measles infections in America.....and the deaths. 

“I started my training 20 years ago in India,” Dr. Sunil Muthusami, a pediatric hospitalist at a community hospital in Lancaster, Pa., told me. “I saw measles there. I did not think I was going to come here and see measles.” His hospital, which is near the epicenter of the largest active measles outbreak in the United States, has seen more than a dozen children come in with pneumonia, respiratory failure and brain inflammation as a result of the disease.


The hospital’s newborn intensive care unit had to open what’s known as a negative pressure unit — a space with specialized ventilation that is part of the most intense form of hospital infection control — to prevent the spread of measles. The children whose brains are affected (suggesting the virus may be causing neurological infection or inflammation) or who need ventilators are transferred to other hospitals that have pediatric intensive care units.

In 2000, the United States achieved measles elimination status. This milestone, defined by having no persistent transmission of the virus for more than 12 months, was the result of decades of work, including vaccine mandates in schools. Now, with more than 5,400 confirmed cases of measles reported so far this year, hundreds hospitalized and 10 deaths, we have joined a handful of countries that have officially lost that status as a result of persistent transmission. This is a moral and medical tragedy, as well as a political failure.

You can talk about smallpox, as I do in my undergraduate classes, with a comfortable sense of curiosity and progress: That was terrible, and now it’s gone. The moral of the story is that international cooperation and scientific progress eliminated a terrible source of human suffering. When I was training in pediatrics in Boston in the 1980s, we couldn’t quite feel that way about measles, but we felt as though we were on our way, thanks to public health and a country that wanted its children to be safe. This essay is an elegy for a lost epidemiologic status, but also for that feeling — and for the people who are dying so unnecessarily now.


Measles ­could theoretically be eliminated from the planet, like smallpox was. Like with smallpox, measles infects only humans, and we have a safe and effective vaccine. 

But measles is much more infectious than smallpox, so if it still exists in the world and we give it a foothold by having a population that is not fully vaccinated, it will come back, hanging in the air on the bus even after an infected person gets off, pervading an elementary school classroom or a sports stadium.

Dr. Muthusami told me that when families come in with a very sick child, often from Amish communities, they frequently report that the entire family has had the virus. 

Although the Amish faith does not forbid vaccination, its adherents have vaccination rates below the U.S. average, in part because many Amish people do not engage with the traditional medical system or do not trust it. 

Dr. Muthusami suspects that reports on the number infected undercounts the amount of virus “actually out there.” He worries about children who seem to recover but can get sick again later. That’s because measles can suppress the immune system for months or years, and leaves patients at higher risk for severe infections, like pneumonia and sepsis.

Dr. Bonnie Zehr, a longtime pediatrician in Lancaster, is encouraging early vaccination for infants in her care, following state recommendations for outbreak areas. The regular recommended age for the first dose of the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine is 12 to 15 months, but an extra dose can be given safely as early as 6 months. We pediatricians would offer this additional, early dose if a baby were traveling to a country where measles had not been eliminated, such as India. But now, some doctors are offering it for domestic travel and to infants living near outbreaks.


Many of Dr. Zehr’s patients who are not members of the Amish or Mennonite communities still choose not to vaccinate their children, despite the outbreak, she said. “Somehow I’m not able to reach them,” she said.

Pediatricians throughout the country are dealing with greater hesitancy around immunizations, fostered by the anti-vaccine sentiment now present at the highest levels of the government. 

Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the secretary of health and human services, has spent years spreading fear and disinformation about the M.M.R. vaccine. Measles may be a harbinger of other dangers if vaccination rates continue to drop. Dr. Walter Orenstein, director of the United States

Immunization Program from 1988, to 2004, told me that he feared a return of polio or Haemophilus influenzae Type B, a deadly vaccine-preventable bacterial infection.

“A milestone has been reached,” Dr. Orenstein and his colleagues wrote in The Journal of Infectious Diseases in 2004, detailing all the strategies that got us to elimination status, including the importance of high community immunity and the power of school vaccine mandates. “For the first time, the public health community has documented that one of the most contagious diseases, a disease that has thwarted more than two decades of attempts to eliminate it, is no longer endemic in the United States.”

“I wish we didn’t have to go back,” Dr. Muthusami told me this week. “It almost seems like we want to make our mistakes again and learn from them again.”

Dr. Perri Klass is a professor of journalism and pediatrics at New York University and the author of “The Best Medicine: How Science and Public Health Gave Children a Future.”

Labels: , ,

President Joe Biden said Donald Trump "sounds like he is ruling from Moscow"- IOW Trump s a Russian asset

 

Donald Trump kowtows to Moscow

Echo opinion letter published in the Scranton Pennsylvania, The Times-Tribune


Dear Editor: Donald Trump fails to support democracy. His autocratic and fascist behavior is wreaking havoc on democracy in America. His failure to support Ukraine (a democracy) is evident in his well-established support for Russia (an authoritarian regime). Trump’s “diesel deal” with Russia is contrary to the position of the majority of Americans, and in particular to the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act. The ‘diesel deal” made illegally with Russia will have a negligible impact on diesel fuel prices in America, but may result in a “Trump Tower”, in Moscow.


Trump, when a young man, was a draft dodger (a coward), too frightened to serve in the military during the Vietnam War, and now, an old man, continues his cowardice and lack of commitment to democracy in America. My opinion is that Trump wants Russia to win in Ukraine. 

From: Gerald Ephault, Wilkes-Barre Township, Pennsylvania

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, November 16, 2026

Maine Senator Susan Collins abandoned her Margaret Chase Smith opportunity but blames constituents for her election loss! WWWTP?

Senator Susan Collins never had a Margaret Chase Smith moment


Collins compared her defeat to that of Maine’s pioneering female senator. But Senator Smith made her mark by standing up to a demagogue- Senator Joe McCarthy. Collins never did.

U.S. Senator Margaret Chase Smith (R-ME) and Senator Joseph McCarthy (R-WI) are best known for her historic 1950, (she called it a Declaration of Conscience speech) floor speech challenging McCarthy’s unverified communist accusations and fear-based tactics. 
“It’s precisely because she didn’t have a true Margaret Chase Smith moment that Collins was beat, I think,” Larry Tye, author of “Demagogue: The Life and Long Shadow of Senator Joe McCarthy,” told me via email. “That moment for Smith wasn’t her being defeated at the end of a long career, but making that career about conscience and standing up to a demagogue when nobody else would.”

She also said she did not want to see the Republican Party “ride to political victory on the Four Horsemen of Calumny — Fear, Ignorance, Bigotry, and Smear.”

While her speech did not end McCarthyism, it focused national attention on it in a way that Collins never tried to do with Trump. Instead she held herself out as a political centrist who knew when to challenge Trump, when to hold back, and how to push the levers of power for her constituents.

For a while, it seemed that might be enough. The Maine Senate race was complicated by the candidacy of Graham Platner, a Democrat who excited the party’s base until several controversies, including a rape allegation, which he denied, drove him from the ticket in July. Jackson, the former Senate leader who replaced him on the ballot, is not known for charm or charisma. When he said “Oh, shut up” to Collins during a debate, I suggested that, to Jackson’s detriment, it might be a defining moment in the campaign.

It was not.

Collins’s appeasement of Trump mattered more. As reported by the Times, while Collins broke “with her party more than any other Republican senator,” her defections “rarely thwarted the president during his second term.”

After her loss, Collins told the Times “Everybody ignores the fact that I voted to convict him in the second impeachment trial. What bigger break could there be
❓ It is never enough. I want results and they want angry rhetoric.”

But as Andrew Shuttleworth Fowler wrote for the Maine Press Herald, Collins did get results — just not the results that Maine voters wanted, from losing the federal constitutional right to abortion to high fuel prices because of the Iran war. Noting that Collins uses a desk that once belonged to Smith, he said Collins inherited the furniture but not “the nerve.”

Smith’s “moment” came on June 1, 1950, when as a freshman senator she delivered a “Declaration of Conscience” on the Senate floor. While she never spoke McCarthy’s name, she essentially denounced him for turning that body into “a forum of hate and character assassination sheltered by the shield of congressional immunity.”

In her 15-minute speech, Smith went on to say, “It is high time for the United States Senate and its members to do some real soul searching and to weigh our consciences as to the manner in which we are performing our duty to the people of America and the manner in which we are using or abusing our individual powers and privileges.”

True “Americanism,” Smith said, embraces the right to criticize, to hold unpopular beliefs, and to protest. “The American people are sick and tired of being afraid to speak their minds lest they be politically smeared as ‘communists’ or ‘fascists’ by their opponents. Freedom of speech is not what it used to be in America. It has been so abused by some that it is not exercised by others.”


Ms. Smith, who served in the Senate from 1949 to 1973, died in 1995 at 97. Collins, who met her when she was a senior high school student visiting Washington, called her a mentor and an inspiration.

Tye told me that when he interviewed Collins for his book, she understood what made her predecessor stand out in history. Yet, while Collins had studied Smith’s legacy regarding McCarthy she “never did stand up to Trump in more than a symbolic way,” he said.

Maine voters wanted something more. They wanted conscience. They wanted moral clarity about right and wrong.

They wanted what Collins didn’t give them — a Margaret Chase Smith moment.

Maine Writer post-script: Senator Collins was given ample notice from voters, especially when Governor Janet Mills labeled her as "always concerned, never courageous", for not standing up to Donald Trump. She was forewarned in letters to the editor and from numerous constituent petitions. But Senator Collins made the decision to accept nearly unlimited amounts of GOP Senate PAC money rather than respond to her constituents' petitions. In the end, her campaign money spent was wasted. Campaign advertising costs would have been able to pay for health insurance premiums for everyone in Maine who lost their Affordable Care Act subsidies. Now, whatever money is leftover from her campaign bucket is hers to keep, while her constituents continue struggling to pay for health care, housing, fuel and food. 

Labels: , ,

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Donald Trump unscripted during his startling 60-Minutes interview with journalist Ross Douthat



Echo analysis by Margaret Hartmann published the New York Magazine "The Intelligencer". 
6 Stunning Moments From Trump’s 60 Minutes Interview

Donald Trump’s discussion with Ross Douthat on 60 Minutes, which aired Sunday night (November 15), was the most interesting interview he has done in some time. Theoretically, Trump was on friendly turf. The conservative columnist, who joined the CBS newsmagazine program over the summer after 17 years at the New York Times, may not be Trump’s biggest booster. But the entire show has just undergone a MAGA-y makeover under new CBS News editor-in-chief Bari Weiss, and Douthat is a far cry from, say, recently departed CBS correspondents Anderson Cooper and Scott Pelley.

As always, everything Trump said must be taken with a grain of salt. The interview was taped Friday afternoon, and since then, Donald Trump has already made moves that contradict what he told Douthat. But, it’s still a fascinating snapshot showing where Trump’s head was at the end of the Susie Wiles era and how he responds when someone respectfully pushes him to slow down and reflect on the wild things coming out of his mouth. Here are some of the most notable moments.

Trump started with the same explanations he’s been giving all week for the GOP’s midterms drubbing, pointing to the fact that he wasn’t on the ballot and his decision to go to war with Iran (which he defended). When Douthat pushed him to drill down on what went wrong, he eventually wound up at “I think it was bad messaging, maybe by me.”

That may be why Donald Trump was relaxed and (relatively) introspective through nearly the entire interview, even as Douthat asked unusual and probing questions on topics like immigration, Trump family corruption, and forgiving your enemies.

But, the correct answer is actually “bad leadership, definitely by me.” But it’s unusual for Trump to admit blame at all.
Check the 60 minutes link on X/ here.

Donald Trump has already reversed himself since this 60-Minutes interview. On Truth Social on Monday morning, he baselessly suggested that Republicans lost the midterms because they were rigged, not because he did anything wrong.

When asked about something he might work on with Democrats, Trump pointed to immigration and acknowlwedged that his deportation agenda was perhaps too harsh.

“I think it might be too tough, yeah,” he said. “I think ultimately that hurt me.”

Trump went on to suggest that law-abiding undocumented immigrants should maybe be able to stay in the country:

"When you go into a hotel and you have a woman that’s worked there as– you know, as a maid, as a cleaner, as a this, as a that, as a waitress, a lotta good things, great jobs, and all of a sudden, they’re being taken outta' the country, it’s tough. It’s a tough thing. But, there’s a group of people that I would say on the sort of pretty far right that would like everybody taken out."

Check the link on X/Here

Name which politician vowed to deport 11 million people or more back in 2024
❓ Trump doesn’t remember❗ He may have already forgotten what he said to Douthat too. Hours after the interview was recorded, he made (evil❗) Stephen Miller his new chief of staff, to replace Susie Wiles.

A week ago, Donald Trump saying he might not endorse a successor might have made J.D. Vance’s soul leave his body (well, more so than it already has). But after Tuesday, maybe it’s better if Trump keeps his 2028, opinions to himself, as he noted.

Trump said that, aside from the vice-president, he thinks Marco Rubio would be a “great” 2028, nominee and that “there’s some senators that are excellent. I know ’em all. I like ’em a lot.” He added, “I may or may not get involved. I don’t know. Maybe I’m better off not getting involved.”
Read the link on X/Here


Donald Trump did get a bit testy when Douthat deftly pushed him on corruption. Douthat pointed to the Trump family’s ownership of World Liberty Financial, noting that if the Biden's had a cryptocurrency company tied to the government of the United Arab Emirates, it would have caused Donald Trump to lose his mind.
Trump said the two scenarios are different because he divested from his family’s companies (“But no, you didn’t,” Douthat countered). Plus, he added, “Every president has had this problem.” Trump suggested that even Washington was sullied by his financial ties to “whatever crypto was at the time, okay
❓” Read the link on X/Here.

Trump also asserted nonsensically that he’s only getting so much flak for his corruption because he’s such a monumental historical figure. “I’m a bigger name than other presidents, whether we like it or not,” he said.🤥🤥🤥

Douthat snuck in one weird question that a lot of people want to ask: What does the president know about aliens❓
🛸👽 Donald Trump said he’s “not too much of a believer,” but it kind of sounds like he is:

"I sat in the Oval Office first term and a little bit second term meeting with Air Force pilots that are really good, solid people. These are not people that you would say are conspiracy theorists. But they’re great, great pilots. They’re the real deal. And they’ve told me things that are very strange. They said that — in, in certain cases — they said yes, there’s something going on out there. Because they’re flying an F-22, which is the best there is, the fastest, the best plane that anyone’s ever seen. And then, something goes by them at three times their speed and it’s round. It’s not aerodynamic; it’s round." (Gee..."aerodynamic" is  very big word for Donald Trump. He has no idea what it means.) Check the link to X/Here.

Donald Trump has been offering sporadic updates on his odds of getting past the pearly gates for several years now. When asked on his current chances, Trump said, “I’m a religious person, so in theory, I go to Heaven.”

Douthat pressed him to go deeper, asking if he’d give up on hating foes such as James Comey and Nancy Pelosi if that was his only path to Heaven.

“Honestly, Ross, can I — can I be honest
❓” Trump said after some deliberation. “I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will.”

Labels: , , , ,

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Incompetence is epedemic in the failed Donald Trump administration- RFKjr causing preventable measles deaths

 Opinion: Impeach and Remove RFK Jr.

The incoming Congress has several avenues to pursue Secretary Kennedy's impeachment. Fire RFKjr.❗

When the new Congress convenes on January 3, 2027, Secretary of HHS Robert F. Kennedy Jr. should be impeached by the House of Representatives and then removed by the Senate.
Can this be done
❓ Yes. Although classically associated with presidents, impeachment applies equivalently to federal officials. 
A simple majority vote in the House, triggers a Senate impeachment trial. Removal occurs if two-thirds of senators agree the official engaged in "...treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors."

Just two cabinet secretaries have been previously impeached, the most recent being Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas in 2024. 

Also of note, articles of impeachment already were filed against Kennedy in 2025 by Rep. Haley Stevens (D-Mich.).

What Is the Goal of Impeachment❓

Impeachment can serve many purposes even without removal: the personal and professional embarrassment of the impeached official or to bring information to light through document discovery and the compelled testimony. Politicians can also grandstand during impeachments and drive points home for votes. 

For example, when the House impeached Secretary Mayorkas in 2024, his probability of removal was zero as the Senate was controlled by the other party, which opposed his impeachment. A trial of merits then never even occurred as the Senate voted to dismiss. As a result, the process was arguably performative.

The goal of Kennedy's impeachment would be removal from office because he is dangerous to public health -- because without it, more Americans will needlessly suffer and die. That is the only goal in my mind.

Which Arguments Could Kennedy's Impeachment be Based Upon❓

Several options exist to pursue Kennedy's impeachment. All appear valid, and we don't have to select just one, though each also has strengths and weakness, pros and cons.

One avenue is looking at dereliction of duty, particularly in our ongoing measles outbreak. The number of American measles deaths should be zero. It was zero for years, and safe, effective vaccination exists. A single measles death is an unacceptable tragedy laid at the feet of pernicious leaders such as Kennedy. Now, the U.S. is on the brink of losing its measles elimination status, pending the outcome of the Pan American Health Organization meeting.

These arguments mirror those of Mayorkas' impeachment alleging incompetence at managing the southern border, therefore endangering Americans. It's also emotionally resonant as we are all watching the measles outbreak stack caskets in real time.

But "dereliction" and "competence" could prove qualitative rather than explicitly provable. Kennedy, for example, could claim that HHS is doing its best though measles is simply an intractable foe.

A stronger argument may thus lie in his cancellation of $8.9 billion in biomedical research grants. Unlike degrees of dereliction, grant cancellation is an unassailable fact that violates Congress' "power of the purse" as the funds had been earmarked. Regardless of party, if Congress approves funds for an expenditure then the expenditure should be discharged. For congressionally funded programs, the executive branch is executor, not executioner.

The administration's multi-front assault on research draws less attention than deserved given its long-term harm. A generation of medical scientists is being kneecapped, laboratories are shuttering, universities reeling. This magnitude of harm is incalculable because it is unknown -- what are the future cures that are now lost?

Is Removal Likely❓

Even if impeachment proceeds, Kennedy's removal is a separate question. Removal in the Senate requires 67 votes; an admittedly high bar, never before achieved. The new Senate makeup is still pending narrow races. However, the final party distribution also shouldn't matter, as removal cannot be partisan in the first place. 

At 67 votes, removal will require both parties, so a politically centered impeachment would end with Kennedy still secretary. But questions of basic competence and our country's health should not be partisan.

Would a sufficient number of senators from both parties vote to remove? One lesson hopefully learned in this midterm election is that, regardless of party, politicians embrace unpopular figures at their peril, and Kennedy is deeply unpopular. The anti-vaccination movement is disproportionately loud, especially with conspiracists now in positions of power, though this fundamentally misrepresents voters' overwhelming support of vaccines. So, an electoral argument could resonate with a senator on either side of the aisle.

Kennedy's anemic support would likely further erode through the discovery process if impeachment proceeds. He's performed dismally during prior congressional testimony, as one would expect from someone with no formal training -- or even real-world work experience -- in healthcare, medicine, or science. The new Congress is on track for a record number of physicians, with doctors who support vaccination sitting on both sides of the aisle in both chambers. How many times have physicians, called before Congress, faced grilling from legislators who are lawyers
❓ Now a lawyer, Kennedy, may face questions from leaders who are doctors.
So, is removal ultimately likely
❓ To be frank, no, it remains definitively uphill. But it's worth pursuing.

What Are the Risks❓

Several counterarguments to impeachment exist, including the discretion given to the executive branch in managing agencies and the fact that senators previously voted for instatement while well aware of Kennedy's conspiratorial incompetence. 

There's also genuine concern for establishing precedent in which future secretaries become routinely impeached by opposing parties. Prior to 2024, there had only been one executive impeachment, and now there could be two in short order. (Meanwhile, the recent effort to impeach Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth was blocked.) And finally, the effort would be an uphill battle, with the risk of Kennedy emerging stronger should removal fail.

But Kennedy is a historically dangerous individual. How many deaths emanate from his secretary-ship and how many more will die if his power is left unchecked
❓ In our work every day, doctors bravely contemplate actions for which we balance risk against the possibility of lives saved if successful. This is no different. Impeachment is fraught, and there are risks, but we have, in the coming months, a window of opportunity with action demanded by the net calculus of consequences.

Meanwhile, another preventable measles death is reported in Wisconsin.  A second child died from measles in Wisconsin this year, the state Department of Health Services announced, as the outbreak there has grown to its largest in more than 35 years, reported by Chloe Rosen for CBS News.  As of Friday, November 13, 2026,  the department had reported close to 650 measles cases in 20 counties, officials said. It's the highest number of cases Wisconsin has seen in more than 35 years.

Paula Tran, Wisconsin's state health officer and Division of Public Health administrator, urged families to get the recommended vaccinations and to stay home if they may have been exposed.

Labels: , , , ,

A Blue Wave election 2026 retrospective: Where will MAGA go now?

‘There’s No Juice Left to Squeeze From MAGA’

Echo opinion in The New York Times by Robert Siegel, E.J. Dionne Jr. and Timothy P. Carney
More than a week after the blue wave, what comes next for both parties
❓

The 2026, midterms last week on November 3,  upended assumptions about where — and how — both political parties can win. So what comes next
❓ 

Opinion contributor Robert Siegel joins the contributing writer E.J. Dionne Jr. and the senior political columnist for The Washington Examiner, Tim Carney, to debate whether MAGA can outlast Donald Trump and what Democrats can do with their new power.

Below is a transcript of an episode of “The Opinions.” We recommend listening to it in its original form for the full effect. You can do so using the player above or on the NYTimes app, Apple, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube, iHeartRadio or wherever you get your podcasts.

The transcript has been lightly edited for length and clarity.

Robert Siegel: Since the three of us last talked, the political map of America has been redrawn. Assumptions about which party can win which state have been thrown out, and past speculation about the future has been replaced with fresh speculation about the future. And before we dig into some of the big questions that arose from the 2026, elections, I’d like to hear, briefly, from each of us about what impression of the election sticks in the mind
❓
What sums up what’s happened most vividly for you❓ Tim❓

Tim Carney: For me, it’s proof that the Donald Trump realignment that we first started to see in 2016, was not really a partisan realignment, but an emergence of what I call “the Trumpy vote.” 
If you look at the counties in Ohio, for instance, that swung most from Mitt Romney to Trump — the places where they’re not necessarily conservative Republicans, but they were Trump voters — those Trumpy counties, those were the counties that had the biggest blue wave. Same thing happened — I looked precinct by precinct level — in Lower Bucks County, the blue collar part right outside of Philadelphia.

Siegel: In Pennsylvania.

Carney: In Pennsylvania, right outside of Philadelphia. Trump came in and won these, what Sean Trende used to call, “the missing white voter.” Those guys, sons of former factory workers, those are the precincts that swung back to give Democrats a House seat, the State Senate, that sort of thing. So, I don’t know whether it’s a matter of Trump voters staying home, or what seems more likely from the numbers so far, that the Trump voter was never a conservative, never a Republican, and now he just voted Democrat.

Siegel
: E.J.
❓

E.J. Dionne Jr.: I got two numbers and two little postcards from my experience of the campaign. Two numbers: Democrats got 56 percent of the popular House vote on the basis of the count right now. That is exceptional. We’ve never seen a blowout like that in decades. The Gingrich “revolution” was with 51 and a half percent of the vote.

Siegel: In ’94.

Dionne: In ’94. Apparently, Republicans haven’t hit 56 percent since 1928. Four and a half million fewer Republicans at the latest count; 15 million more Democratic votes. So this was both a dispirited Democratic base and mobilization. Two postcards: Covering Adam Hamilton — Rev. Senator-elect Adam Hamilton. It’s the only campaign I ever covered, where part of my work was going to a wedding that he performed as a minister, and a baptism — and I think that tells us something about him and the nature of this campaign.

And lastly, I went down to Mississippi, because I’d heard some really good things about the kind of candidate Scott Colom was. I walked into a place called Johnny T.’s Bistro and Blues in Jackson, and I sat down with Scott Colom. He laid out exactly how he could win that race. And it was an extraordinary understanding of that race. And I’ve got to say, he made me a believer — that this really could happen. And he proved, as he said in his speech, that it wasn’t just about faith, it was also about work, because he wouldn’t leave Johnny T.’s before he had shaken every hand in the house. He really worked that race.

Siegel: To which I would add, from myself, the political power exercised by Southern Black voters, even after, and in large part in reaction to, the gutting of the Voting Rights Act. It was so great in Georgia, in Mississippi, in North Carolina — you can say Texas is part of the South. It was pretty strong in Louisiana. And it left me wondering if the Voting Rights Act, a great landmark piece of legislation of the 1960s, really had, as many conservatives argue, outlived its necessity. E.J., feel free to scold me for that heretical statement.
Dionne: How’d you know I disagree with you, Robert
❓ When you look at Colom’s victory, what did it take❓ You still had very quite racialized voting in Mississippi. It just happened that Colom was skillful at bringing over enough white voters and a massive turnout of Black voters. Why❓ Because they fundamentally disagree, obviously, with what you just said. They believe — and I think they’re right — that knocking down the Voting Rights Act enables the kind of gerrymandering that you saw in Tennessee that also happened. In Tennessee, the Republicans split up Memphis, which is about 60, 65 percent Black, not into two pieces, but into three pieces, just to make sure that that vote couldn’t affect the results.

Justin Pearson, a brave state legislator who’s Black, ran in one of those districts. He ran a great race. The national wave was with him, and he still could only get to within one point. So I think what we really need is a new Voting Rights Act, but we also should have national outlawing of gerrymandering. Because I think that when you think about environmental laws, we have them so that somebody doesn’t try to cut their price by polluting a river. We say to employers, people, manufacturers: “Sell a better product, but don’t pollute the river.” And I think we’re polluting the river of American politics with competitive gerrymandering, which is going to keep going until we outlaw it.

Carney: I agree that partisan gerrymandering — it’s a scourge on democracy. I also agree that part of what the Voting Rights Act was being used to do was to mandate racial gerrymandering. This is part of the case in Louisiana. If you remember those horrible districts in North Carolina a couple decades ago, that were drawn with these little threads along a highway — that was racial gerrymandering to make sure that there are enough majority-minority districts.

So I absolutely agree that we need to get rid of the gerrymandering, the partisan stuff. We also need to get rid of racial gerrymandering. And Democrats would not be happy with that, because in some states they depend on tying together two different minority precincts.

Siegel: Let’s talk about the two big parties right now. The devastating defeat the Republicans suffered this year raises the question: Is MAGA dead? Who wants to start on this one?

Carney: I mean, the political analysis that I was mentioning earlier, the Trump vote, the working-class white vote that Trump brought into the party, never became reliably conservative and Republican. These people weren’t made into Paul Ryan acolytes who love the idea of reforming Social Security. And frankly, they’re not the Ted Cruz vote from 2016. Remember, you could chart by county. The places where people were more likely to go to church every week in the 2016, primaries, they were voting for Ted Cruz.

The places where you had the white evangelicals who don’t attend church, they were more likely to be the Trump voter. So the less religiously observant, the less fiscally conservative — that was the Trump vote. And the Republicans cannot rely on them now that Trump is leaving the stage. 

And then, you combine with that the fact that the party started selecting for loyalty to Trump, rather than either conservatism or quality of candidate — and that also hurt the party. So going forward, the Republicans, there’s no juice left to squeeze from MAGA. And if anybody tries to be a mini MAGA — if JD Vance says, “I’m going to be the next Donald Trump” — you can’t be the next Donald Trump.

I mean, we’re New Yorkers. We remember this guy. He is sui generis, (IOW "of its own kind" or "in a class by itself") thanks be to God, and there isn’t another one of him. I basically think Trump blew up what existed before the consensus — the Reagan consensus that lasted for a while — but nothing has filled that space.

Siegel: I just want to underscore what you said about candidates. I was thinking, boy, a lot of Senate Democrats who won Senate elections were lucky to have a terrible opponent. And then it occurred to me it’s not luck that you get Herschel Walker running for the Senate, only because loyalty and fame have been elevated to values that dwarf every other talent that a candidate might have.

Dionne: Look, I think that MAGA is dead as such, because it was always rooted in a contradiction. The great economics writer for the Financial Times, Martin Wolf, once described it as “pluto-populism,” which was plutocratic populism.

And I think, in this version of Trump, he gave voters the pluto without the populism. And that his ties to very, very wealthy people were just so obvious to so many of these voters, and the obsessions with things like the ballroom and the like, that they just walked away. Now, does it mean that a strongly conservative wing of the Republican Party is gone
❓ No. There’s always been that. The Tea Party, in many ways, gave birth to the MAGA movement. So there will be a right wing of the Republican Party, but MAGA specifically defined by Donald Trump — and this odd contradiction of policies that often help the wealthiest people, but rhetoric that was directed to working people, usually using tariffs as his way in — I think that just will not work anymore.

Siegel: Tim, how would you see a Republican Party minus MAGA
❓ Is it back to the Ted Cruz appeal❓

Carney: I mean, when I talk to conservative Republican circles, they want to, I say, get the band back together. And they think that the way things were and that when they lost in 2012, you know, Romney should have won that — that is a perfidious (
deliberately faithless, treacherous, deceitful, or untrustworthy) pipe dream for conservatives. Part of the problem was that they were ignoring the big difference and why some populism was needed between the elites of both parties and the public of both parties.

I said this last time I was on the show. Both parties’ elites have long been internationalists on war, trade and immigration, while the public was not. So a more nationalist party — and I know that nationalism sounds like a bad word to a lot of people — but you can have nationalism without it requiring what Trump did. Say, in Minnesota, siccing cops on protesters; immigration enforcement that’s basically “bust the heads and haul off anybody.”

Dionne: And kills people.

Carney: Yeah. So there is a nationalism that says our immigration policy should be crafted for the people who are here, and our foreign policy should not be listening to what NATO and the E.U. say, but looking after American interests.

I mean, in my view, the trade policy that serves us best is basically free trade. But all of those things — be more guided towards nationalism, but in a smart way, not driven by a Trump who says: I love tariffs, they’re my favorite word. So a saner, calmer, but more nationalist-focused conservatism could be one of the paths forward for a post-MAGA conservatism.

Dionne: “Perfidious pipe dream.” I’ll have to credit you when I use that. I think that Tim is right about something important, which is that the Trump victory did show that for many years now, the Republican Party has relied a great deal on white working-class voters. And Ross Douthat and Reihan Salam wrote a book years ago, about the Republicans not doing anything for that white working class.

The problem is, they still haven’t done very much about the white working class, and what you saw in this election was something like a more authentic populism, I would argue, coming from the Democratic side, which said, “Look, it’s not populist to cut people’s health care off by cutting Obamacare subsidies. It’s not populist to kowtow to big tech companies. It’s not populist to let data centers run rampant without any local control.” And so, I think what you’ve got is a bunch of loose voters again, who are open to persuasion. But if the Republicans go back to a kind of pure Reaganite or Paul Ryanite politics, I don’t think there’s a majority there for them.

Carney: But I think a conservative populism can be a real thing. For instance, again, immigration. Is the immigration policy directed at driving down low-skilled wages? Which a lot of our immigration policy has been. Let’s bring in guest workers. Maybe we need them for seasonal work, but do we need them in the factories? Maybe that would be better going to the people who are here, natives, or current immigrants who don’t have a college degree or a college education. Similarly, big government, as we saw with Trump’s tariffs — that often serves the guy with the best lobbyists, which is not going to be mom and pop. So I do think a more conservative populism is possible. Obviously, a very different one than Trump’s. And I think you’re right that the Democrats seized the populism mantle this year, but I don’t think that that’s inevitable going forward.

Dionne:
You know, under Trump, real wages are down. Manufacturing jobs are not up. And so — if I may channel the late Walter Mondale — where’s the beef
❓🐮🐄
Siegel: Let’s move on to the Democrats, who won nearly everything that could be won. They have big majorities, but not a veto-proof Senate majority. And some of the people who might have crossed the aisle to vote with them in recent years — Susan Collins of Maine, Thom Tillis of North Carolina — are no longer there. There are Democrats holding those seats. So what can the Democrats actually do with all these seats in Congress
❓

Carney: They can investigate Donald Trump. And I’m going to say, not that the average Democrat will listen to my advice, but there are places where there is clear evidence of corruption in the Trump administration, which is self-enrichment. Whether it’s selling crypto — worthless crypto tokens that then the top buyers get — a dinner with Trump; whether it’s his son’s business in the United Arab Emirates or Qatar. We could keep going on with a lot of these. The revolving-door lobbyists, the firms that are close to them, what special deals did they get❓ In short, were there quid pro quos❓
Did Donald Trump, or anybody in this administration, give any political favors to people who were personally enriching his family or enriching the people close to him❓

I bet the answer is yes, and that’s where I’m hoping the Democrats look. I’m afraid they’re going to get distracted by Jeffrey Epstein noise, or by Russia again, or something like that. They need to focus on what really corrodes policymaking in this country, and what Trump was pretty guilty of, it seems to me, which is selling policy for personal favors to the president and the people close to him.

Dionne: So I’m going to do something dangerous. I’m going to say that the Democrats actually will be more disciplined than Tim suspects. And if you listen to one of the leading people who’s going to be looking into all this, Jamie Raskin, he is speaking in a very disciplined way, because he knows what the Democrats are up against here.

Siegel: We should say he’s poised to be the next chair of the Judiciary [Committee].

Dionne: Thank you. And so, I think they do know that a mishmash of too many hearings doesn’t penetrate anything. But they’re also not going to make the mistake of all investigations, no legislation. And I think they already have a plan to pass some very simple, broadly popular things in the party as early as they can, particularly reversing these health care cuts, trying to hem Trump in on the tariffs, particularly with Canada, which are very unpopular in the country. And also, take steps to end the war in Iran. And I think the problem Democrats have is that they don’t know which Trump they’re going to be dealing with. I was so struck that on the same day ——
Siegel: When he said he would work with the Democrats❓

Dionne:
Trump gave our former colleague, Ross Douthat, an interview in which he said that the immigration policy was too tough, and he’d like to negotiate a deal with the Democrats. Later that day, he named (evil❗) Stephen Miller, the architect of that policy that was too tough, as his chief of staff. They’re now threatening criminal action, if the Democrats exercise their constitutional right to oversight. So, they don’t know what they’re going to be dealing with. The rubber will really hit the road on the budget, because the one thing they have to agree on, at some point, is a budget. The budget can pass on reconciliation, the rules that allow a party to pass stuff in the Senate without 60 votes.

Siegel:
Without a filibuster.

Dionne: Without a filibuster. And then you’re going to have a negotiation, and I think Democrats will put some of the stuff they want that is very popular — like restoring health care money — in that bill, and we’re going to see what Trump really wants to do.

Carney: Also, we’re going to see if Democrats believe in taxes anymore. It used to be that Democrats would say: “We’re going to tax people.” Now the Democrats are piling on finding new people to not tax. Four hundred thousand — is that now the limit? If you make less than 💲400,000, so many Democrats say, “We’re not going to hike your taxes.” So, that’s one point of pressure on them: Are they willing to say, to balance the budget, to reduce the deficit, etc., “we need to increase taxes”?

Democrats of old loved increasing taxes on anybody who was above the middle class, or even in the middle class; and now it seems that they’re allergic to it, in part because that upper middle-class electorate has moved so far to the Dems.

Dionne: Two things: One, there is so much money given away to the super rich in the tax code, since 2000 — the two Bush tax cuts and the two Trump tax cuts. I think there is a lot of money to be raised just there, to fund what the Democrats think they might be able to do in this period. But I think the honest, most likely thing is neither party is going to deal with tax increases until after the 2028 election, because I think Trump would veto that anyway. And we’re going to have the big argument about budgets and the future of Social Security after 2028.

Siegel: Who are some stars of the Democratic landslide and how might they figure in the coming presidential election?

Carney: I think Jon Ossoff is the one that won all the buzz coming out. Georgia was a state that 20 years ago the Republicans took over, and now it’s got — statewide — Democratic elected officials. And Ossoff seemed like he was at the cutting edge of that.

On the other side, though, I would say I think Josh Shapiro, the governor of Pennsylvania, is the one who comes out of this the biggest loser, in part because now he has a trifecta. He was pretty good working across parties, and Dems would say: Hey, he gets stuff done. Remember, he fixed I-95 in a week or something.

But now he’s going to have the pressure from the liberals who are now controlling the state legislature to pass stuff that Tim Walz was handicapped by — the governor of Minnesota who was Kamala Harris’s running mate. He was handicapped because he got pushed to pass all sorts of things, either the special interest asks from the teachers’ unions or massively high minimum wage or other things that could really hobble the economy.

So I think of Ossoff as a winner and Shapiro as a loser.

Dionne: Tim thinks everything progressives want to do is unpopular. Strengthening health care is popular, child care is popular, building more housing is popular, raising the minimum wage is popular. I think that’s actually good for Shapiro because he needs to move to the left a little bit to have a chance to win the nomination.


But you can go down the list. James Talarico is a star. Roy Cooper is an unheralded star. I think Roy ——

Siegel: Governor of North Carolina.

Dionne: Yes, of North Carolina. I think Roy has not gotten enough kudos because he put the race away so early that it really didn’t get a lot of attention. I don’t think he’s a presidential candidate, but I think his achievement is really going to be studied.

And I think that Abdul El-Sayed is going to be one of the most interesting people in the Congress. I think you’re going to see El-Sayed try to develop into more of a national candidate. For example, he started out being Medicare for all, and then he amended a little bit to Medicare for all who want it, which is really the public option, which is the compromise position Democrats can agree on. So I think he’s going to be a fascinating person to watch.

Siegel: According to Gallup, close to half of Americans identify as independents, even if they lean one way or the other, they go out of their way not to identify as Democrats or Republicans, perhaps just to avoid fund-raising phone calls. I don’t know why they do it.

Dionne: I get emails from Donald Trump trying to raise money.

Siegel:
Does the shrinkage of party identity, party affiliation in the country, mean that there is this vast pool of people who are up for grabs in every election❓


Carney: Up for grabs, yes. But one of the dreams that people get is, oh, well, if half of the country — and that’s bigger, that’s a plurality if it’s 49 percent — we can form a third party that can win. That 49 percent doesn’t agree on very much, so this includes, again, your working-class white guy, who wants more spending on Social Security, but also tariffs. And it includes your moderate country-club voter who wants lower taxes, medium regulation. It includes every sort of thing. So a key thing to remember is that 49 percent might agree that both parties stink, but the next item on the agenda, you’re going to have a lot of disagreement.

Dionne: Tim has found something we emphatically agree on. But what I want to say is, somebody years ago wrote a book called “The Myth of the Independent Voter,” and a lot of independents aren’t really independents. The pollsters now ask, do you lean ——

Carney: Who did you vote for last time
❓ Who did you vote for❓

Dionne: But I do think there’s something that friends of a party system — and I think you can’t have a democracy without parties — have to acknowledge that the rising desire to identify as independent is, in some ways, a sign of alienation from the system.

Carney: Yeah.

Dionne: A sense that the system isn’t delivering. We are not happy with these politicians. I think there is something real there that both parties have to grapple with.

Siegel: One interesting feature of this year’s Democratic candidates was the relative comfort that several showed with the language of religion, in describing themselves and their ideas about governing. Senator-elect Hamilton of Kansas is a pastor. James Talarico of Texas is a seminarian. Scott Colom in Mississippi began his victory speech with a long riff on prayer and faith. Just a coincidence or is there something big at work here❓

Carney: This was the silver lining of the election for me, that these were Democrats who were very comfortable in talking about faith and not just as a personal thing. If I can quote from some E.J. Dionne columns here — Adam Hamilton said: “The gospel isn’t just about a personal faith. It’s about the call to be in the world.” Scott Colom: “When we talk about policy issues we need to talk about it through a faith and values lens.” This is a very important thing that, I think, we struggle with as a country because we rightly see that religion shouldn’t be legislated.

We shouldn’t mandate that people go to church. We shouldn’t impose, through legislation, some specific religion. We can’t establish a religion. But there’s this myth that we should just take our religion out of our brain when we’re talking about politics, or ask our elected officials to do that, too. And the fact is that, if you’re passing a policy — if you’re going to go ahead and say, actually, no, we’re going to expand Medicaid. Why are they doing that
❓ Again, Scott Colom says, well, it’s a biblical duty to serve the poor, not just that it would be good to keep people from starving.

As a Christian, you have to believe that you have to feed the hungry. You have to clothe the naked, house the homeless. This is actually a duty. They think you can do it through the government, and the point is that they are informed by their religion in their policymaking. I think that this needs to be more broadly accepted. And as we become more pluralist, as we get Muslims in the United States Senate, maybe it’ll be easier for us to say, “OK, yes, individual lawmakers and voters are going to be informed by their religion, nobody’s going to impose their own.” But the idea that religion has no place in the public square, that’s a really destructive idea.

Dionne:
That was a warmly, “love thy neighbor” thing to do, to quote my column. So thank you for that. And maybe this whole thing is affecting, coming into this room. Two things: I broadly agree with that. A lot of Democrats were religious before and didn’t talk about it. John Kerry is a good example, where he spent a year, after 2004, talking to a lot of theologians; basically asking, “Why was I tongue-tied on this
❓ How could I talk about it❓” So it is a myth that Democrats were all godless all those years. That just wasn’t true.

On the other hand, it is very clear that Democrats did find a way, partly because of the nature of the candidates themselves, to talk more about this. And by the way, just if I can put a parenthetical in here, Black politicians have always been very good at talking about faith. And what you saw with Scott Colom was deep in his own tradition. But yes, I think what you’ve got is Democrats being much braver about saying, “We want to have an argument about faith. We want to talk about what faith really demands of us.” And I think they are trying to replace the culture wars with a much broader moral argument. I’ve been writing about this, this year. And the biggest compliment to Democrats is that they talk so much about faith that when the Republicans couldn’t attack them as being anti-religion, they attack them as heretics. And as I tell some Democratic friends, that’s a big improvement for Democrats.


Robert Siegel: But are northern liberal Democrats — who might attend a house of worship for weddings and funerals and little else — ready for a Jimmy Carter-like invocation of faith in political discourse
❓

Dionne: I think these candidates have found ways of making very clear that they know they live in a pluralist democracy with a First Amendment. Adam Hamilton has been very clear on that. The Republicans actually attacked Adam Hamilton for saying that non-Christians could go to heaven. And Ted Cruz did that. And I actually wrote, what will Senator Cruz tell his Muslim constituents down in Texas about their eternal life❓ So I think all these candidates signal that they’re pluralists at heart, but they’re believing pluralists.

Carney: And again, an important thing is that religion does belong in the public square and in the public discussion, not as one religion imposing on the other. But Nancy Pelosi once said, when she was being asked about how the Democrats could support the case against the Little Sisters of the Poor, and said: Well, you’re a Catholic. Why are you going to force these nuns to provide contraception❓ And she said: “I do my religion on Sundays.” A poor slip of words, but you can’t just do your religion on Sundays. To be a Christian, a Jew, a Muslim, etc., it has to be part of your life. And so, that religion belongs in the public square is something I’m really hoping that a Hamilton and a Colom can advance.

Dionne: If you look at the record, Pelosi actually has talked a lot about the public implications of religion, but ——

Carney: And she goes to Mass too, not just on Sundays. So yes.

Siegel: OK, one last question. What did you guys make of the vote to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and the Democrats who were stuck in traffic and deprived that motion of a possible majority❓


Dionne:
You know, Italians have this wonderful word that translates as “behindology,” and you never take anything at its surface. And I would love to know why those 11 were not there. I agree that Beltway traffic can be awful, but that was rather astonishing. And is there some move to postpone this to their time in office
❓ Because I think that should have gone through. We should have a debate, in the Senate, where there are a lot of Republican critics. So I still am not satisfied with the explanations we’ve heard.

Carney: And yeah, a dog caught the ambulance that it was chasing, and it didn’t know what to do with it. That’s the interpretation that this wasn’t just an accident. If it was an accident, it doesn’t speak to Democrats being good at governing. But some of those charges, why they would be brought against Hegseth as opposed to the president — going to war without congressional authorization, too. Is Congress really who handed this ball over, who were derelict on their duty to declare war? Are they now going to try to impeach the defense secretary for doing it
❓

Dionne:
This is one of the most destructive defense secretaries in history. I think it’s a good idea, and you would be the first to say endless impeachments of Trump didn’t work out so well. Really zeroing in on abuses here, I think, is a good idea — and we should do it.

Siegel: OK. Well, listen, it’s been great hearing you guys on politics. It’s time now for us to wrap up, as we do in every one of these conversations, with something, some source of joy in your life over the past week or more, that you would share with us. Who wants to start?

Dionne: Go ahead. You start it.

Carney: So, Twitter was actually good for a day. And that was Veterans Day. First, my brother went ahead and posted that our dad, John Carney, was a captain in the U.S. Army, but both of my grandparents were in the military. I had a great-grandfather who was a brigadier general in the Marine Corps. You can go back to the Irish Legion, in the Civil War, to find my ancestors. And then to watch other people proudly post their husband or their wife as a veteran, and posting pictures of their dads.


And something about the Vietnam generation, they just looked a little cooler in uniform than anybody else. And so, to watch the celebration of veterans in people’s families and communities, I thought, “Wow, I’m going onto Twitter and coming away feeling better.” That’s a rarity. So that brought me joy.

Dionne:
I appreciate that. You know, my dad and sister, and a lot of my students at Georgetown, actually were, or are, in the military, and thank you for that. I’ve got to say my joy is political this week, and it’s particular. One is we had a free and fair election. A lot of us were worried about whether we would. A lot of us worried about where the administration would intervene. Now, I think the lack of intervention was in part because a lot of people, including a lot of lawyers, organized and stopped certain things in their tracks. But maybe somebody inside the administration said, “No, there’s a limit to how far we can go here.” We still have to always be alert, but that was a great thing.

My other joy was just to be part of history and go down to Mississippi, and watch Scott Colom do what he did there, and be a figure who, at the same time, recognized the sacrifice of earlier generations of civil rights heroes and martyrs — and he talked about them — and also spoke resolutely about building a multiracial coalition: Now your kids are going to be as important to me as my kids.

He really did an extraordinary historic thing. And I don’t care what your politics are, to have Mississippi elect the first Black senator since Reconstruction is a big deal for the country, and it was really cool to be able, in a small way, to be a witness to that.

Siegel:
You bet. And for my part, I would say that my wife and I gave in, to the urgings of a daughter and various friends who told us all to go see, “You Can See Everything,” a three-hour-long documentary. But to call it a documentary doesn’t do justice to the improvised form of this movie. It’s fascinating, and it’s all about how to determine what is true, what is sincere, what’s fraudulent, what’s phony. And I found it just one of the most thought-provoking things I’ve seen in a movie theater in quite a while. I recommend it to you all.


Guys, thank you for that. Tim, E.J. — wonderful seeing you again.

Carney: My pleasure.

Dionne: And may all elections be as fun to discuss.

Labels: , , , ,